CCC Forum

I have to admit of being something of a sucker when it comes to unusual lenses, so when I saw a Kickstarter campaign by Lomography for a modern update of the first lens designed specifically for photography I was always going to be interested. I managed to resist the lure of Lomography's earlier Petzval based creations and having seen the results I am glad that I did. I am not sure that swirly bokeh is really my thing and would soon tire of the effect. This new lens has a completely different look and feel to it, though, and is something I might actually use. Soft wide open, it still has a dreamlike quality at the smaller apertures.

It was not long before I got my credit card out after returning home from last night's club meeting. I had missed the $300 and $350 offers, but managed to get in on the September delivery of a brass lens at $400. When I started looking, 61 were available which went down to 54 in the short time I was online. Earlier on today there were just 13 remaining, now all gone. October delivery at the same price remains plentiful, but with the publicity it is garnering around the Internet and just one day into the sale that situation is unlikely to last long. With the Kickstarter funding goal already achieved, I now have until 10 May to consider my purchase before my credit card is charged. Maybe a filter and some vaseline would be more cost effective?

I did think about the black lacquer version, but this is a fascimile of a lens the date of which coincides with the start of the Victorian era. It can only be brass.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/lo ... -64-art-le

I wondered about the petzval lens, and this one as well. Will be interested to see how you get on with it!

davidc wrote:I wondered about the petzval lens, and this one as well. Will be interested to see how you get on with it!

It's getting a poor reception from the DPReview crowd. Anything they don't like must be good, right?

If I am honest, it is probably more of a novelty than something I would use on a regular basis. As my card will not be charged until 10 May when the Kickstarter fundraiser finishes, I have a bit of time to decide if I want to pay that much for what is essentially a toy.

I found this article at The Online Photographer which states that around the turn of the last century photographers were not necessarily looking for the sharpest optics and preferred something with a bit of diffusion. It's out of fashion these days, but that's the effect I am seeing with this lens and I do quite like it.

http://theonlinephotographer.typepad.co ... atter.html

Found this review.

http://www.thephoblographer.com/2016/04 ... weOs3ro4gu

It's not really an apples-to-apples comparison but the Lensbabys I have are quirky and fun and very rarely taken out of the cupboard.

davidc wrote:It's not really an apples-to-apples comparison but the Lensbabys I have are quirky and fun and very rarely taken out of the cupboard.

That's the concern, of course, that it might just be a five minute wonder. Even if I were to get a worthwhile shot out of it, I might well have a judge complaining that the result is soft.

I am planning to leave it for now and will revisit the decision closer to the time.

Here's another "special" lens from a different manufacturer. I think that I am going to pass.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/me ... rioplan-f2

I don't mind it but don't think I'm such an afficionado of bokeh photography that I'd go and buy one.

Lensbaby is getting in on the act with one that looks very "Petzvally" too - http://lensbaby.com/usa/twist60lens.php

davidc wrote:I don't mind it but don't think I'm such an afficionado of bokeh photography that I'd go and buy one.

That's pretty much what I thought. I prefer the bokeh from the Achromat, the bubble effect does not do much for me and I found it distracting.

davidc wrote:Lensbaby is getting in on the act with one that looks very "Petzvally" too - http://lensbaby.com/usa/twist60lens.php

Yes, I had seen that. I also saw where someone had achieved the same effect by having a hole cut into black paper placed in front of the lens.