Wratten Lecture - share your thoughts
Posted: Thu 21 Mar 2013, 09:10
First of all I wanted to say thanks to Bill for his organisation and choice of speaker, very good work and well done.
Thought it might be nice for club members to discuss what they liked (or disliked!) about the talk, collating it in one place and perhaps feeding back to Damien eventually?
Anyway, I'll kick off
I thought there were a number of interesting points, including the one Mike mentioned about drawing a circle a mile around your house and focusing efforts within. I also really like the three square crop shots that formed a nice triptych of the chap walking past the ascending steps and looking for an "image" that isn't just composed of a single frame. What surprised (and pleased) me most though was his emphasis on the emotional impact of an image and communicating something to the viewer - no comments about highlights at the edge of the frame, or composition (bar one or two remarks), it was all about seeing a scene and taking the time to render it in such a way that you communicated your vision. THAT I really liked and it was refreshing to hear! I was also pleased there was very little "gear talk" too and although he stopped short of echoing Chase Jarvis' "the best camera is the one you carry with you" quote, he certainly seemed to have the spirit of that quote!
It also tickled me to hear the faint intake of breath when he showed the palm tree shots with the extraneous branches cloned out... I wondered if he'd mortally offended some of the crowd then but I think his comment that photography isn't about creating a perfect series of record shots was 100% valid and one I share, and it seemed like he won people over.
I must confess I'm not a fan of Amateur Photographer magazine and had a little trepidation when hearing it was him speaking - the mag discussion sections seem to be people focusing on "film v digital" arguments, bickering over the use of photoshop and lots of people simply arguing back and forth (read the freebie magazine, only one letter is NOT a complaint of some description!). Therefore to hear him just talk about photography and simplicity was VERY nice indeed.
All in all I was pleasantly surprised and come home with a number of ideas and thoughts swimming around in my head. Job well done to Damien and Bill!
Thought it might be nice for club members to discuss what they liked (or disliked!) about the talk, collating it in one place and perhaps feeding back to Damien eventually?
Anyway, I'll kick off
I thought there were a number of interesting points, including the one Mike mentioned about drawing a circle a mile around your house and focusing efforts within. I also really like the three square crop shots that formed a nice triptych of the chap walking past the ascending steps and looking for an "image" that isn't just composed of a single frame. What surprised (and pleased) me most though was his emphasis on the emotional impact of an image and communicating something to the viewer - no comments about highlights at the edge of the frame, or composition (bar one or two remarks), it was all about seeing a scene and taking the time to render it in such a way that you communicated your vision. THAT I really liked and it was refreshing to hear! I was also pleased there was very little "gear talk" too and although he stopped short of echoing Chase Jarvis' "the best camera is the one you carry with you" quote, he certainly seemed to have the spirit of that quote!
It also tickled me to hear the faint intake of breath when he showed the palm tree shots with the extraneous branches cloned out... I wondered if he'd mortally offended some of the crowd then but I think his comment that photography isn't about creating a perfect series of record shots was 100% valid and one I share, and it seemed like he won people over.
I must confess I'm not a fan of Amateur Photographer magazine and had a little trepidation when hearing it was him speaking - the mag discussion sections seem to be people focusing on "film v digital" arguments, bickering over the use of photoshop and lots of people simply arguing back and forth (read the freebie magazine, only one letter is NOT a complaint of some description!). Therefore to hear him just talk about photography and simplicity was VERY nice indeed.
All in all I was pleasantly surprised and come home with a number of ideas and thoughts swimming around in my head. Job well done to Damien and Bill!